All Topics / Help Needed! / How much can we borrow?

Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 23 total)
  • Profile photo of SavSav
    Participant
    @sav
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 32

    I have 3 close friends that wants to join my property investing portfiolo and worked out we can pay up to $4,500 per month in repayments. Were actually looking around different areas to do a small project to get small business started. How much could we borrow estimation, we earn at least 55k p.a. We really want to get started in the property business. Any suggestions????

    Profile photo of Richard TaylorRichard Taylor
    Participant
    @qlds007
    Join Date: 2003
    Post Count: 12,024

    As mentioned to you in our email correspondance without knowing how much actual cash you have to put in the equasion it is a difficult question to answer.

    To buy a standard residential property which needs refurbing will require a cash imput of around 6-10% of the purchase price merely to cover the acquisition costs plus the amount required to renovate or reburb the property.

    If you can afford $4500 / month then probably a good idea to start a Bank account and in 3 months you should have saved nearly $14,000 between you. That at least will be a start. 

    Richard Taylor | Australia's leading private lender

    Profile photo of ScampScamp
    Member
    @scamp
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 297

    You're asking the wrong question. The right question is "How much should I borrow to be able to safely survive a depression ?"
    The answer is well-known : maximum 3 times your gross wages. So if you earn 50.000, you should borrow MAXIMUM 150.000$, and make a deposit of 15.000$ cash.

    Profile photo of SavSav
    Participant
    @sav
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 32
    Scamp wrote:
    You're asking the wrong question. The right question is "How much should I borrow to be able to safely survive a depression ?"
    The answer is well-known : maximum 3 times your gross wages. So if you earn 50.000, you should borrow MAXIMUM 150.000$, and make a deposit of 15.000$ cash.

    What can you buy with 150k?

    Profile photo of ScampScamp
    Member
    @scamp
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 297
    Sav wrote:
    What can you buy with 150k?

    There's plenty of houses for sale for 150k.

    Profile photo of harbharb
    Member
    @harb
    Join Date: 2006
    Post Count: 324
    Scamp wrote:
    Sav wrote:
    What can you buy with 150k?

    There's plenty of houses for sale for 150k.

    Yes, but would YOU buy them ? There are either in places like Wilcannia or somewhere you'd spend 3 hrs and $300/week to get to work. May as well find a place in the sticks for under 50k and retire on Centrelink benefits.
    Reminds me of Mitchel QLD about 5 years ago when Johnnie doubled the FHG for a while. All the real estate in town sold out in a few days and some buyers were even getting refunds from the leftover FHG

    Profile photo of ScampScamp
    Member
    @scamp
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 297

    Well, anywhere else the houses are overpriced. What did you expect ? To buy a penthouse in Sydney for 8.000.000 with a 50.000 wage ? I'm just telling you what your options are : Close to none.

    And together with you , 99% of the people looking for houses have 0 options either. So , houseprice will come down since noone can afford them. Easy enough. Don't invest in property for at least a few years.

    Profile photo of harbharb
    Member
    @harb
    Join Date: 2006
    Post Count: 324
    Scamp wrote:
    And together with you , 99% of the people looking for houses have 0 options either. So , houseprice will come down since noone can afford them. Easy enough. Don't invest in property for at least a few years.

    There are always options, you may not see them clearly or are to scared of the options but they are there.
    "Don't invest in property for at least a few years" , what kind of bs advice is that ? At any one time there are different market forces at work in each state even down to each suburb level. Or maybe you think you will scare enough investors to cause a price collapse to a level you can afford to buy in? If so you are dreaming and will remain a renter for the rest of your life. Sure it can be scary to jump in but remember that Risk =Rewards.

    When I bought my first IP for 45k back in 1985 CBA and NAB knocked me back because based on my 10k gross earnings I couldn't even come close to affording it. They were probably right but I managed to score a loan with T&C anyway and struggled to make repayments for the first 2 years before the wage and rental increases caught up with the repayments and I could afford it. By 1989 when the interest rates went up and prices doubled in Perth I couldn't afford to buy another IP but bought one anyway and struggled with even higher interest rates until wages and rental increases caught up with the repayments. Since then I've bought a few more properties which I couldn't afford at the time that are now +ve geared and will remain so even if we turn into a banana republic with interest rates at 18% again. If I was to follow your advice and waited for house prices to come down to a level I could afford I'd probably still be waiting to buy my first IP.

    Profile photo of YossarianYossarian
    Member
    @yossarian
    Join Date: 2006
    Post Count: 136
    harb wrote:
    When I bought my first IP for 45k back in 1985 CBA and NAB knocked me back because based on my 10k gross earnings I couldn't even come close to affording it. They were probably right but I managed to score a loan with T&C anyway and struggled to make repayments for the first 2 years before the wage and rental increases caught up with the repayments and I could afford it. By 1989 when the interest rates went up and prices doubled in Perth I couldn't afford to buy another IP but bought one anyway and struggled with even higher interest rates until wages and rental increases caught up with the repayments. Since then I've bought a few more properties which I couldn't afford at the time that are now +ve geared and will remain so even if we turn into a banana republic with interest rates at 18% again. If I was to follow your advice and waited for house prices to come down to a level I could afford I'd probably still be waiting to buy my first IP.

     

    If you *seriously* bought property you knew objectively you couldn't afford, you didn't invest, you gambled.

    Good that you won.

    Not good advice to provide to others in the current climate IMHO

    Profile photo of yarposyarpos
    Member
    @yarpos
    Join Date: 2004
    Post Count: 247
    Sav wrote:
    Scamp wrote:
    You're asking the wrong question. The right question is "How much should I borrow to be able to safely survive a depression ?"
    The answer is well-known : maximum 3 times your gross wages. So if you earn 50.000, you should borrow MAXIMUM 150.000$, and make a deposit of 15.000$ cash.

    What can you buy with 150k?

    wasnt the whole point that there is a group of you?  using scamps logic thats $150k each if you are earning about $50k each

    Profile photo of harbharb
    Member
    @harb
    Join Date: 2006
    Post Count: 324
    Yossarian wrote:
    Not good advice to provide to others in the current climate IMHO

    First, I 'd like to say that I'm no adviser so I couldn't possibly advice anyone and it shouldn't be taken as such.
    Secondly , I found the best time to buy property or shares is when the market is looking gloomy. Like in the current climate, interest rates at or near the peak with lots of sellers and very few buyers and imminent wage increases.
    And thirdly , Life IS a gamble. You're taking a gamble whenever you cross the road yet that doesn't stop you from doing it. Hopefully after you do the research first by looking Right and Left and calculate the risk.

    Profile photo of devo76devo76
    Member
    @devo76
    Join Date: 2007
    Post Count: 542

    Not all houses are overpriced. I hate this broad statement. In my area i bought a house that i admit i paid too much for. Not crazy money just around $20,000 more than should have. Live and learn. But if i was to take the building out of the equation it leaves my land value at around $80,000. Thats close to pre 2001 boom prices. My point being there are pockets of realestate that are in good locations and good value. I am constantly spotting properties at around replacement cost now.Take all comments with a grain of salt as there are many posters around at the moment trying to organise a coordinated attack on investing.See through it and try to listen to a more balanced opinion from both sides.

    Profile photo of SavSav
    Participant
    @sav
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 32
    harb wrote:
    Scamp wrote:
    And together with you , 99% of the people looking for houses have 0 options either. So , houseprice will come down since noone can afford them. Easy enough. Don't invest in property for at least a few years.

    There are always options, you may not see them clearly or are to scared of the options but they are there.
    "Don't invest in property for at least a few years" , what kind of bs advice is that ? At any one time there are different market forces at work in each state even down to each suburb level. Or maybe you think you will scare enough investors to cause a price collapse to a level you can afford to buy in? If so you are dreaming and will remain a renter for the rest of your life. Sure it can be scary to jump in but remember that Risk =Rewards.

    When I bought my first IP for 45k back in 1985 CBA and NAB knocked me back because based on my 10k gross earnings I couldn't even come close to affording it. They were probably right but I managed to score a loan with T&C anyway and struggled to make repayments for the first 2 years before the wage and rental increases caught up with the repayments and I could afford it. By 1989 when the interest rates went up and prices doubled in Perth I couldn't afford to buy another IP but bought one anyway and struggled with even higher interest rates until wages and rental increases caught up with the repayments. Since then I've bought a few more properties which I couldn't afford at the time that are now +ve geared and will remain so even if we turn into a banana republic with interest rates at 18% again. If I was to follow your advice and waited for house prices to come down to a level I could afford I'd probably still be waiting to buy my first IP.

    So what would be your advice for me to do at the moment. Ive got $20,000 cash in the bank, i earn 55k p.a and my gf earns 40k p.a. I just wouldnt know where to start because of the house prices around melbourne is too much for me to afford but if there is a way, im very discipline with money and willing to jump in the market.

    Profile photo of ScampScamp
    Member
    @scamp
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 297

    Sav : Every month , houseprices go down by 5% or more.
    Why the hell would you buy now when you can buy for half the price in 1 year ?

    Profile photo of SavSav
    Participant
    @sav
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 32
    Scamp wrote:
    Sav : Every month , houseprices go down by 5% or more.
    Why the hell would you buy now when you can buy for half the price in 1 year ?

    hrm…..thats a good point i thought it was a good time to buy because everyone is selling not buying. Im just very eager to get into the market and been delaying it for a long time till now.

    Profile photo of harbharb
    Member
    @harb
    Join Date: 2006
    Post Count: 324
    Sav wrote:
    So what would be your advice for me to do at the moment.

    Couldn't give you any advice but I am surprised to hear that with 95k p.a you can not afford much in Melbourne. I suppose its not about how much you earn but rather how much you can save and how much does the tax man takes away at the end of the year.
    Have you done your homework in the area you want to "jump in" ? Is there any particular reason for choosing Melbourne or even VIC, other then because is near you ? Anything that would increase the value of your chosen area above others near it ?
    If it was me I'd go with what devo76 said, look for an area with good sized blocks older houses and development potential down the track and find something at or below replacement value from a desperate seller. With prearranged finance I'd start with an offer 20% bellow the asking price, worst thing that can happen is they tell me to f**k off. Then once I got it I'd give it a quick paint job, rent it out and grab all the tax benefits out of it. After a few years maybe I'd look at developing the land. But that's only me. You'll need to do your homework and see what works for you, what risks are you prepared to take and be comfortable with, what sacrifices are you prepared to make in order to achieve the final goal. Only when you know that you should be ready to jump in.
    Best of luck

    Profile photo of devo76devo76
    Member
    @devo76
    Join Date: 2007
    Post Count: 542
    Scamp wrote:
    Sav : Every month , houseprices go down by 5% or more.
    Why the hell would you buy now when you can buy for half the price in 1 year ?

    Another crap statement. If houses where to go down 50% in 1 year as you have stated in my area that would mean my house is worth around $150,000. It would cost more than that to build so the land must be worth nothing hey. I will admit that many areas are looking a bit dodgey over the next few years. But if you want to start now look around. There are areas that are not currently in a so called bubble situation. Find them.Pick the best property you can afford. Not the dearest,the best,( Position,sub potential,reno potential,improving local infrastructure and economy). Bargain hard and you will be ok. Sure it may drop a bit more but when the market  turns you will  already be off and racing thinking about the next IP you want to buy>

    Profile photo of v8ghiav8ghia
    Member
    @v8ghia
    Join Date: 2005
    Post Count: 871

    I may as well contribute a bit of a summary of the above with a few thoughts…
    1) Usually people that 'wait' for the market to be 'best', never actually get into it.
    2) Re prices – I thik a lot of people are fussy, and I can see a gradual exodus to areas where house are more affortable. It makes sens if you want to own your own home and maintain a reasonable lifestyle.
    3) For investment, regardless of where the so called property cycle is, there is always value buying around – sub $150k, or otherwise – all depends what you can afford – and how much neg gearing you can service. It is a type of 'forced saving' after all.

    Investing in property IS a good time now , as is getting outside your traditional 'comfort zone' a bit – however speculating on sudden jumps in value, rennovation projects, gambling, buying off the plan, overpriced surfers paradise units, and not doing a bit of good old fashioned due dilligence……..is what shouldbe avided now!

    all the best on your (our?) journery…..

    Profile photo of ScampScamp
    Member
    @scamp
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 297
    devo76 wrote:
    Scamp wrote:
    Sav : Every month , houseprices go down by 5% or more.
    Why the hell would you buy now when you can buy for half the price in 1 year ?

    Another crap statement. If houses where to go down 50% in 1 year as you have stated in my area that would mean my house is worth around $150,000. It would cost more than that to build so the land must be worth nothing hey. I will admit that many areas are looking a bit dodgey over the next few years. But if you want to start now look around. There are areas that are not currently in a so called bubble situation. Find them.Pick the best property you can afford. Not the dearest,the best,( Position,sub potential,reno potential,improving local infrastructure and economy). Bargain hard and you will be ok. Sure it may drop a bit more but when the market  turns you will  already be off and racing thinking about the next IP you want to buy>

    Wake up Devo. Haven't you heard ? We're heading global recession, hyperinflation in USA, fannie and freddy are down 90% !!!! What the hell are you thinking ? That your house will be spared ? hahah you amaze me. Houses are being sold cheaper than they cost to build all the time, in fact in USA if you buy a house that costs more than it cost to build, you're a sucker, please wake up and you will see that this is all coming to Australia too, and it will be MUCH worse in Australia. Your house could be worth 300.000 now, in 2 years it will be worth 150.000. Accept it.

    ps : did you hear the newest trend in USA ? "Buy 2, get 1 for free !" ( HOUSES… that is , not vegetables )

    Profile photo of ABC_reporterABC_reporter
    Participant
    @abc_reporter
    Join Date: 2008
    Post Count: 3

    Hi Sav,
    I work as a producer for ABC TV. We are looking for case studies or people in varied financial situations who are looking to buy to include in our panel discussion on the Great Australian Dream… we hope to have financial advisors assess different situations and forecast the right outcome for them. Im on [email protected] if you are interested.

Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 23 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. If you don't have an account, you can register here.