Hi Pepper,
Welcome to PropertyInvesting.com – I hope you find lots of worthwhile information to guide your steps.
Re your question (ocean views vs flat lot) I would first mention that I don’t know Perth (I’ve never been there). But some thoughts re Real Estate are universal, so my thoughts will be ignoring the city and just comparing the two options.
First, I would suggest checking comparables for both properties. What values do “ocean view” properties of a similar style (once done up) fetch? Are you able to buy it cheaply enough to cover the cost of renovating, and gaining some Equity?
I don’t know the R20/R40 zonings – I would guess the R40 might allow extra density into the future – is that right? If so, then that has a value favouring the “flat land” property. Also, from your words, the “Flat land” one is ready to rent (no reno required?). What about rents? Do the rents favour one over the other?
With comparable land sizes, the differences are “views” vs “development gains”. Let’s assume that the reno is complete on the “views” house – what is its value then? From that point on, the views cost you nothing – whereas to take advantage of the “development” house, a lot of time/cost needs to be applied.
My thoughts would be that IF the views house doesn’t require too much major work (cost) and its value then jumps way more than the cost of the reno, then I would be favouring that one. The idea of being built on a sand dune is a bit worrying though !! Eeekkk…. Sorry – no definitive answers, but hopefully a bit of food for thought,
Benny