After many years of great discussion, we've switched off new topics and replies. Every thread stays right here though, so you can still browse and search the whole archive any time.
For up-to-date chat with fellow investors, come join us on Facebook:
I've just stumbled upon this site today and i wished I knew about it earlier . I thought I had a good (novice) plan in the works but that seems to be unravelling before my eyes and would appreciate any advise .
We ( hubby and me ) currently have a PPOR (propety A) in both our names , we bought it for $430K and have managed to make extra repayments to the amount of $165K and now only owe $127K to date. There was an offset account attached to this loan. I have an IP (property in just my name ( bought it before we got married) and currently owe about $218K . The grand plan I hatched was to move into the IP (due to personal reasons) and make ( into PPOR and switch (A) to an IP. I would redraw the $165K from A to repay B paying if off in full ie discharge the loan. I was only looking to stay temporary at B (5 – 7 year outlook) and would then like to but a new PPOR (property C) and at this time switch B back to an IP. Being greedy I thought the advantage of my scheme was great coz 1. Property A is an investment and redrawing $165K would increase the loan amount therefore interest expense 2. Be technical mortgage free with Property B for 5-7 years 3. Use the equity in property B to buy a better place and later on still claim interest when it becomes a IP again.
However after reading some of the post I seem to have done everything wrong!!
A. i should have not put extra repayments in A and should have instead deposit in the offset account – i'm trying to reverse this now by redrawing the payments to the offset as I have not moved to property B yet. B. Not consider paying off property B if i intend to make it into an IP again C. Change my time frame to 6 years and under for CGT reason D.Overally Very confused ……
I was looking to be mortagage free for my PPOR and have a effective negative gear in place but i think I've stuffed it up right on the inset. Any help or advise is appreciated!!
I'm a newbie here too – joined in July. I won't offer you any info as I'm not experienced enough but I just wanted to say that I think you've come to the right place.
Everyone here is very helpful and their knowledge is incredible.
If there's a solution, these guys on this site will give it to you.
I've also visited a few other sites that may be able to help in terms of forum advice – happy to give you their details if you e-mail me.
DON'T redraw on Property A at all – leave it as is. Refinance property B once it's become your PPoR and use the cash to pay Property A off completely, therefore making it for investment purposes and tax deductible. Property A will then (presumably) be CF+, contributing positively to your income and helping with your own mortgage on property B. It's not negatively geared but by the same token you aren't paying a whole lot of non deductible interest…
At this stage I'd be calling an accountant real quickly – i.e before you start redrawing or transferring anything.
Sorry to be the bearer of bad news but i think you may have an issue and probably need some rehashing of your structures.
Great in theory Refinance property B once it's become your PPoR and use the cash to pay Property A off completely, therefore making it for investment purposes and tax deductible. but it will not be acceptable to the ATO.
Depending on time frames there are a couple of alternative strategies to consider but they all come with a cost.
In saying this it may well be worth it in the long run and could well be viable to set up depending on the numbers.
Richard Taylor | Australia's leading private lender
Also get a valuation on property B when it becomes a PPOR because if you sell property B in the future you will have a hard time working out which part is subject to capital gains tax and which part is exempt from capital gains tax as a PPOR . Also you will have a similar problem with property A as it has changed from PPOR to investment property and it will also need a valuation done at this point as it is a change in the property status and is deemed as a capital gain event. The onus on record keeping is infinitely longer for capital gains tax events as compared with normal tax records.