All Topics / Legal & Accounting / SMSF ‘loan’ to a non-member?
The forums are being retired.
After many years of great discussion, we've switched off new topics and replies. Every thread stays right here though, so you can still browse and search the whole archive any time.
For up-to-date chat with fellow investors, come join us on Facebook:
Hi
Can a SMSF loan money to a non-member (that is not an associate of a member) at arms-length, and that non-member loan that money at a higher interest rate to a member?
I don't see a problem with loaning money to a non-member that is not a trustee of the SMSF and is not an associate, where the loan is at arms length on commercial terms. (i.e. its akin to a SMSF investing in a government bond that pays a quarterly coupon).
Im concerned whether the subsequent loan from the non-member to the member could be considered to breach the sole purpose test under the SIS Act? The loan would be at a higher interest rate so that should be sufficient to show commercial feasibility.
Any thoughts?
Thanks
AndyHi there
you will need to get proper advice from a superannuation specialist but this smells like a scheme to circumvent the rules for SMSF funds not lending to a related party
you will probably have problems with the sole purpose test – where the scheme is considered in totality
thanksDoes PartIVA of the Income Tax Assessment Act apply to the SIS Act? Or is there an equivalent provision for 'scheme'?
Thanks
http://law.ato.gov.au/atolaw/view.htm?DocID=DSF%2FSMSFR2007D2%2FNAT%2FATO%2F00003
please review the above link in answer to your queries
thanksthanks for the ATO ruling raddles
i take alot of comfort from the following paragraph…
Circumstances that do not result in a contravention of paragraph 65(1)(b)
17. Arrangements where an SMSF invests on commercial terms in an unassociated entity do not result in a contravention of paragraph 65(1)(b) if that unassociated entity, independently of the SMSF and in its own right and from its own resources, gives financial assistance to a member or member's relative.16
would appear to me that based on para 17, a loan to an unassociated entity (eg a third party) at a commercial interest rate, wherein the funds were subsequently on-lent to a member at a higher interest would not contravene 65(1)(b)?
do you agree?HI there
I think you really need to speak to whoever audits your fund – to see how they interpret this.thanks
I will not comment whether such an arrangement would be considered a 'scheme' – but a SMSF cannot give financial assistance to a member or a relative of a member – either directly or indirectly.
The ATO has released a Tax Payer Alert on this subject (in regards to financial assistance via an 'unrelated' trust):
http://www.ato.gov.au/superfunds/content.asp?doc=/content/00259571.htmAlso, from experience, when a SMSF lodges an annual return with 'Loans' listed (Return question 14b, Label H) – they are significantly more likely to have an ATO audit / review – which means that the ATO considers these types of 'investments' a high compliance risk.
Evolve
Grow SMSF | Grow SMSF
https://growsmsf.com.au
Email Me | Phone MeSelf-Managed Super Fund (SMSF) Specialist Accountants




