All Topics / General Property / Am I Nuts – or am I making Money anyway?
The forums are being retired.
After many years of great discussion, we've switched off new topics and replies. Every thread stays right here though, so you can still browse and search the whole archive any time.
For up-to-date chat with fellow investors, come join us on Facebook:
Am I nuts??
I have been reading a lot of stuff especially in the mainstream media about how poor the property market is.
And yes it is flat where I am and in most of Oz.However it appears that the market here is still moving upwards at a “mere” 5% per year.
Doesn’t sound like much compared to the 2004 boom here.
However I keep looking at my neutrally geared investments and how they are leveraged.
Lets just say if an investor held $1.1 worth of assetts and owed $600k onn the lot. ($500k equity and neutrally geared)
He would then in theory be gaining 5% of that $1.1m worth each year.
i.e. $$55,000 per annum before tax.To me that is not too bad, considering the market is stumbling.
Or, to put it another way, 11% gain on the $500k investment.
Am I deluding myself on this?
Why are ppl so negative about property at the moment?What is wrong with this? [blink] [glum2]
Giddo
http://www.standrewsplace.com.auKNOWLEDGE IS POWER
Sounds alright to me. and the market shouldn’t be slow forever. What will the figures look like during the next boom.
Terryw
Discover Home Loans
Parramatta
[email protected]
Sign up to my mailing list.
Just send me a blank email, with “subscribe†in subject line.Terryw | Structuring Lawyers Pty Ltd / Loan Structuring Pty Ltd
http://www.Structuring.com.au
Email MeLawyer, Mortgage Broker and Tax Advisor (Sydney based but advising Aust wide) http://www.Structuring.com.au
giddo – you are completely nuts [biggrin] only joking!
that sounds about right and no doubt certain areas will perform better than others
Positive Cashflow NZ Property Deals.Email to receive current deals & Free New Zealand Information Sheet [email protected]Hi Giddo,
And that is why long term investors generally do very well.
Imagine 5%/annum for 4 years and then a period of high growth.
Your high growth comes off a platform of 20% growth compounded and tucked away against your bottom line.
Derek
[email protected]
http://www.pis.theinvestorsclub.com.au
0409 882 958
Skype – derekjones2113Giddo
The only thing standing between you and mega $$$’s is time!
MikeyAlso, mainstream media is usually based in city centres, therefore they are usually looking at the immediate area surrounding city centres – which as we know has not increased in value (Melb and Syd esp)
I try not to listen to negative feedback otherwise I never have accumulated a successful portfolio…
when my inlaw said “why on earth would you want to buy there – who would live there? and you have never been there and never been in the property?” I just smiled and said nothing

TD
Originally posted by giddo:Am I Nuts – or am I making Money anyway?
Well, perhaps…
At +5% per year, your ‘wealth’ as measured in Australian dollars would be increasing. But it is absolutely possible that your investment is losing value… while its price is rising[blink]
That house can now be traded for more $AU, but paper money does not have a fixed value. Try comparing it to a range of other ‘assets’ and items; oil, gold, silver, beer, iron ore, meat, vegetables, health insurance for just a few examples. You can now trade your house for LESS of each of these than you could have 1 year ago (assuming 5% pa cap gain on house).
Of course in such a scenario, higher gearing works in your favour.
Cheers, F.[cowboy2]
Thanks Foundation,
I have read your very good posts before and I have a lot of respect for your good advice. You are one of the legends of this forum(and there are a few too).
I guess you are right about a lot of commodities gaining in cost quicker than my real estate. (inflation I think it is called)
I sincerely hope I am not in the position of ever having to swap my properties for health insurance or – even meat or vegetables.[biggrin]
At the moment I am trying to resist a yearning for bananas. i believe they will be expensive and higher in value on a % basis than my land and buildings.
The thought of trading my properties for a million dollars worth of beer truly boogles my mind? What brand would I buy? Where would I store it?? Will it’s value keep increasing. Sadly I think beer is like fruit and veg it has an expiry date where re does not.[blink]
The only things I suppose I may have to consider would be swapping it for GOLD , SILVER or IRON ORE. Nah In am too scared of losing it.
On second thought I have decided I will stick with the RE. [evo]Maybe I will just use a bit of the income to buy beer and veges.
Despite the foregoing disrespectful facetiousness, you do have a good point about the dangers of inflation.[goatee]Giddo
http://www.standrewsplace.com.auKNOWLEDGE IS POWER
Good example giddo – thats how i look at real estate.
If you make 5% on $1.1m you are in effect making a return of $55,000 on your $500,000 equity. Thats over 10% in a flat market.
Thats good in my books.
see I knew you weren’t nuts giddo[thumbsup2]
I Buy New Zealand Property – All types and conditions [email protected]
With all due respect I’d rather make 50% or more a year than 5 or 11%. With $500,000 I’d control more than $1m….thats why my portfolio is larger than most.
In fact, I’m more interested in cash flow then I am in asset growth because with cash flow I can buy more assets than I can with asset growth. Thats why I’m investing in the US because I can get 10-20% rental return with say no money in…. that gives me an infinte return….not 5 or 10%.
<snip> leave the trawling please Andrew – Derek
Andrew




