heres a quick rundown of my situation.
I have 2 investment properties that are neutral geared on the Sunshine Coast. I live in a rental which is owned by my parents and rent it cheap. We are on a single income and my partner is off to Uni this year so we need to move to Brisbane or commute there 3 hours a day.
Here is the problem
I want to purchase a property to be PPOR for 4 years in Brisbane then convert it to a rental but dont have the income to aquire a quality property (the bank will finance me but thats because they know they cant lose out).
However I can afford to buy another investment property because we would have rent to subsidise the repayments.
If I use the equity in my existing properties to finance the PPOR it still doesnt help because where ever I get the money from (savings or equity) I would be stretched to meet the repayments.
Is there a simple solution to this – of course I dont want to sell my investments.
[confused2]This is not a catch 22. You want something that you can’t afford, that’s life! It sounds like you’ll either need to sell one of your units or rent.
hmmm I know your right Foundation but renting in my opinion is such a waste of money. Maybe I’ll have to change my direction and look for a cheaper alternative. eg: townhouse or unit not a freestanding house [glum]pfsfinanceMember@pfsfinanceJoin Date: 2004Post Count: 171
I’d be looking to buy something cheaper in Brisbane. Also remember in moving to Brisbane you will also save money on petrol/public transport costs. Which can also be factored in.
Development Finance SpecialistluckyoneMember@luckyoneJoin Date: 2003Post Count: 148
Have you thought about buying the place in Brisbane in a trust and renting the property from the trust for you and your partner?
Thanks luckyone. Does this then mean that the trust can then claim for negative gearing purposes even though I would be a director of the trust.[cap]
thanksOriginally posted by Ricksta:
hmmm I know your right Foundation but renting in my opinion is such a waste of money.
In my opinion unnecessarily high interest payments are far more wasteful! Who would you rather the money goes to – the bank or to one of the wonderful ‘investors’ on this forum?[cap] You can rent for less than an interest only (IO=Rent) loan, save the difference, and watch the price of property continue to fall around you. When it bottoms out, use that saved money to pick up a bargain![king]
Go on, you know I’m right, do yourself a favour.Big UnitParticipant@big-unitJoin Date: 2005Post Count: 2
Have you thought of approaching your accountant and discussing a section 15/15? This will aid with serviceability and is accepatable to some Bank lenders. The section 15/15 allows a monthly return from the ATO on your annual interest claim (negative gearing), hence improving your monthly position substantially.
Kurtbyronent_2Participant@byronent_2Join Date: 2004Post Count: 337
Trust can claim negative gearing even though you are the trustee, it is a seperate entity in the eyes of taxation. I am not sure how this will help your problem.
I would like to see numbers go with this query, at this point too hard to help on info provided.
Adelaide SAsalaciousMember@salaciousJoin Date: 2003Post Count: 373
A little bird told me you can get a loan with no interest repayments?
Dom[biggrin]TerrywParticipant@terrywJoin Date: 2001Post Count: 16,213
Trusts can negative gear only if they have other income. losses have to be quarrantined in the trust, so these cannot be offset against other personal income. A Hybrid trust may be a way around this.
I don’t really think renting is a waste of money as long as you are investing the difference (renting is usually much cheaper than paying off a home loan on the same place).
Interest free loans are still not available yet!
Discover Home Loans
Click below to email meOriginally posted by terryw:
renting is usually much cheaper than paying off a home loan on the same place.
Only at this point in the market – the last gasp of a bursting bubble. In a stable market rent is very closely correllated to the cost of mortgage repayment. This is why the phrase ‘rent is dead money’ came from. If the market climate of the last 6 years had dominated the long term such a phrase NEVER would have added up!Interest free loans are still not available yet!
And NEVER will be! Anybody care to buy a solar powered torch that recharges itself with its own light?
SALACIOUS – can you elaborate on no interest repayments!!
thankswoodsmanMember@woodsmanJoin Date: 2004Post Count: 714
Go the the Finance section and you will see a plethora of commentary, insults & verbal sparring over interest free…..
Each time someone asks a question or makes a comment about that topic…I hear re-runs from Faulty Towers…..don’t mention the war!!aussierogueParticipant@aussierogueJoin Date: 2003Post Count: 983
please – rent money is dead money. this is just one of those stupid terms designed to push someones vested interest. the only reason you dont hear ‘interest on mortgages is dead money’ is because landlords dont have a combined voice…Michael WhyteMember@michael-whyteJoin Date: 2004Post Count: 269Originally posted by aussierogue:
please – rent money is dead money. this is just one of those stupid terms designed to push someones vested interest. the only reason you dont hear ‘interest on mortgages is dead money’ is because landlords dont have a combined voice…
I decided to buy my PPOR, but only when I realised that the interest on the loan would be about the same as I was paying in rent, but that I would be living in a big house instead of a crappy little unit. The reason they ended up being the same is because I put $400K down on the house. If I hadn’t then the interest on the loan would have been MUCH more than the rent on the unit.
Of course, I saved all that deposit by renting a cheap place and investing the left over funds. Isn’t brain surgery, but again its amazing how many people would rather pay their “rent” to a bank instead of a landlord and at a much inflated price…
Michael.salaciousMember@salaciousJoin Date: 2003Post Count: 373
Rent versus ownershipp?
Has been discussed extensivley. Would like to hear more views on this topic, very interested especially in this climate of property investing.
My view which is not important is, if you are a first home/ip buyer then buy.
If you have 10 positive geared properties then you have a choice.
No real answer for this just a matter of circumstance but im sure i will have to be correected.
DOM[biggrin]Kiwi-FullaMember@kiwi-fullaJoin Date: 2002Post Count: 371
Here is an idea…
Get a property on a lease option for 36 – 48 months. These are the following benefits (if you negotiate the contracts correctly):
1. Some of what you pay will come off the house price if you buy the property.
2. You get control of the property
3. You get the capital gain if you buy (but pay the old agreed price)
4. You get to rent it (if you choose to) out to someone else at a higher rate than your agreement commitment amount.
5. You can sell the property if you wish to and profit from the higher price difference between your agreed sales price (in your contract) and the new sales price.
6. If you choose to….you can simply onsell your option (for a fee of course)
7. No stamp duty is payable.
8. No bank loan required – WOO HOO
This gives your time to allow your current financial situation to change and gives you plenty of “options” to exit and walk with the profits looking for hte next deal!
Just a thought folks – best of luck!
Kiwi[baaa]myoungMember@myoungJoin Date: 2004Post Count: 33Originally posted by Ricksta:
hmmm I know your right Foundation but renting in my opinion is such a waste of money. Maybe I’ll have to change my direction and look for a cheaper alternative. eg: townhouse or unit not a freestanding house [glum]
Not if you rent something that is in a low yield area and buy an another investment in a high yield one.[buz2]You’ll actually be in a better lifestyle at a lower cost.